Feminist Analysis of Mental Health Law

Most common law jurisdictions have a rights-based model of mental health law - whether procedural or substantive - and individual human rights have become the main normative element in mental health law. There is, however, a growing critical discourse on the nature of the current rights-based model of mental health law - asking not merely what rights should be protected, but whether the protection of rights enough. This book offers a fresh approach to this question as it brings feminist critiques of rights discourse to bear on discussion about re-conceptualising rights in mental health law. Modern feminist work has not engaged to any significant extent with the system or the rights-based model of mental health law. There is, however, a strong discourse within modern feminisms on the nature and role of rights. Succinctly, modern feminist theories of rights recognise the limitations of rights discourse, but also acknowledge the continuing importance of rights as a means to protect vulnerable groups in society. Against a background of the complicated history between traditional feminist theory and the operation of the mental health system, this book draws on these insights and illustrates how they can be usefully applied in the context of contemporary mental health law.

Majoritatea jurisdictiilor de drept comun au un model de drept al sanatatii mintale bazat pe drepturi - indiferent daca este procedural sau material - iar drepturile individuale ale omului au devenit principalul element normativ in dreptul sanatatii mintale. Exista, totusi, un discurs critic in crestere cu privire la natura modelului actual de drept al sanatatii mintale bazat pe drepturi - intrebandu-se nu doar ce drepturi ar trebui protejate, ci daca suficienta protectia drepturilor.